During the May 27 finale of Perfect Match season four, Ally Lewber's night with Hashim Moore became public in front of her love interest, Jimmy Presnell.
Hashim told the cast they were "physically intimate" during their matched night together. Ally had told Jimmy only that they kissed. The Netflix episode then aired never-before-seen footage of the two in bed together, contradicting her account.
When confronted, Ally admitted to Jimmy that she did "just a little more" with Hashim. She specified: "I sucked his dick for literally like 10 seconds. It was literally 10 seconds."
Jimmy stared blankly as he processed the confession, despite having had his own sexual encounter with Ally days prior.
Ally defended herself by saying they were "open" during their time on the show and that she "didn't lie." Jimmy's expression suggested skepticism.
By the end, Jimmy chose the diplomatic route. "We have done things the right way by being open here," he said, adding that he's giving Ally "grace" because their "story was a wild ride."
Neither has confirmed their relationship status since the finale aired, though they have posted TikTok videos together in recent weeks.
This confession comes months after Ally announced her breakup with Vanderpump Rules costar James Kennedy in January 2025.
